patch 20h

RETRIEX_PATCH_20H_TOTAL_COMMERCE_ROUTING_STATUS_FIX_README.md

@@ -0,0 +1,152 @@
+# RetrieX Patch 20h – Total Commerce Routing & Shop Status Fix
+
+## Ziel
+
+Dieser Patch ersetzt die fragmentierten p20d/p20e/p20f/p20g-Nachbesserungen durch einen kumulativen Fix gegen den aktuellen `rag-inprogress.zip`-Stand.
+
+Er adressiert zwei zusammenhängende Fehlerklassen:
+
+1. Explizite oder referenzielle Commerce-/Shop-Anfragen dürfen nicht im RAG-only-Pfad landen.
+2. Sobald ein Shop-/Commerce-Routing erkannt ist, darf die Statuskarte während des Ablaufs nicht weiter `Shop-Treffer: nicht angefragt` anzeigen.
+
+## Behobene Fälle
+
+### Expliziter Shop-Intent
+
+Beispiel:
+
+```text
+shop testomat 808
+```
+
+Erwartung:
+
+- Commerce-Intent wird abgesichert.
+- Shop-Pfad wird betreten.
+- Status springt nach der Intent-Erkennung auf `Shop-Treffer: wird geladen`.
+
+### Tippfehler-Normalisierung bleibt erhalten
+
+Beispiel:
+
+```text
+was kpstet der indikator
+```
+
+Erwartung:
+
+- LLM-/Fuzzy-Normalisierung bleibt erhalten.
+- Die Anfrage kann intern als Preis-/Shop-Follow-up geroutet werden.
+- Es wird keine konkrete Tippfehlerliste eingeführt.
+
+### Referenzieller Tabellen-/Preis-Follow-up
+
+Beispiel:
+
+```text
+welche grenzwerte kann der testomat 808 messen
+
+die tabelle mit preisen
+```
+
+Erwartung:
+
+- `die tabelle mit preisen` wird als kommerzieller Tabellen-Follow-up in den Shop-Pfad gehoben.
+- Die Shop-Query wird aus dem Verlauf robuster abgeleitet, z. B. `Testomat 808 indikator`.
+- Die History wird newest-first durchsucht und nicht nur der letzte Turn betrachtet.
+
+### Status-/Meta-Konsistenz
+
+Sobald Commerce-Intent erkannt ist, wird `shopCountMode` zentral berechnet:
+
+- vor Shop-Suche: `loading` → `Shop-Treffer: wird geladen`
+- nach Shop-Suche: `count` → echte Trefferzahl
+- Shop-Systemfehler: `unavailable` → `Shop-Treffer: nicht verfügbar`
+- Commerce erkannt, aber keine konkrete Suchquery lösbar: `not_resolved` → `Shop-Treffer: keine Suchquery`
+- nur Nicht-Commerce bleibt `not_requested`
+
+Damit gibt es im Shop-/Commerce-Ablauf keine verstreuten harten `not_requested`-Zwischenstatus mehr.
+
+## Geänderte Datei
+
+- `src/Agent/AgentRunner.php`
+
+## Technische Änderungen
+
+- Initialisierung von `$commerceIntent` und `$shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery` vor dem Try-Block.
+- Absicherung gegen Normalisierungsverluste: falls der normalisierte Routing-Prompt keinen Commerce-Intent ergibt, der Originalprompt aber schon, wird der Original-Commerce-Intent übernommen.
+- Frühes Meta-Event `Shop-Routing erkannt` bei Commerce-Intent.
+- RAG-Zwischenmeta nutzt bei Commerce-Intent `loading` statt `not_requested`.
+- `not_requested` wird nicht mehr an mehreren Stellen hart gesetzt, sondern über `resolveShopCountModeForMeta()` zentral berechnet.
+- Referenzielle Tabellen-Follow-ups werden ohne vorherige harte History-Anchor-Bedingung in den Shop-Pfad gehoben.
+- Tabellen-/Preis-Follow-up-Query sucht History-Kontext robuster über Commerce-Kontext, erweiterten Verlauf und optional Full-History.
+- History-Turns werden newest-first geprüft.
+- Wenn ein Indikator-/Tabellenkontext ohne Modell gefunden wird, bleibt ein Fallback erhalten; ein später gefundener Modellanker hat Vorrang.
+
+## Lokale Prüfungen
+
+Durchgeführt in der Container-Umgebung:
+
+```bash
+php -l src/Agent/AgentRunner.php
+```
+
+Ergebnis: OK.
+
+Zusätzliche statische Checks:
+
+- kein hartes `shopCountMode: 'not_requested'` mehr im AgentRunner
+- `not_requested` nur noch zentral in `resolveShopCountModeForMeta()`
+- `loading`, `not_resolved`, `unavailable` und `count` werden zentral unterschieden
+- keine konkreten Tippfehlerlisten wie `kpstet` / `ksotet`
+
+Nicht vollständig ausführbar in dieser Umgebung:
+
+```bash
+bin/console mto:agent:config:validate
+bin/console mto:agent:regression:test
+bin/console mto:agent:config:audit-source --details
+bin/console mto:agent:config:audit-patterns --details
+```
+
+Grund: Die ZIP enthält keine installierten Composer-/Runtime-Dependencies; die lokale Umgebung hat außerdem nicht alle benötigten PHP-Extensions.
+
+## Pflichtprüfung nach Einspielen
+
+```bash
+bin/console cache:clear
+bin/console mto:agent:config:validate
+bin/console mto:agent:regression:test
+bin/console mto:agent:config:audit-source --details
+bin/console mto:agent:config:audit-patterns --details
+```
+
+Falls OPcache/PHP-FPM aktiv ist, danach PHP-FPM bzw. Container neu laden.
+
+## Manuelle Regressionstests
+
+```text
+shop testomat 808
+```
+
+Erwartung: Shop wird angefragt; nach Shop-Routing nicht mehr `Shop-Treffer: nicht angefragt`.
+
+```text
+was kpstet der indikator
+```
+
+Erwartung: Shop-/Preis-Follow-up greift weiterhin über Normalisierung/Fuzzy-Routing.
+
+```text
+welche grenzwerte kann der testomat 808 messen
+
+die tabelle mit preisen
+```
+
+Erwartung: Shop-Suche wird ausgelöst; Query sinngemäß `Testomat 808 indikator`.
+
+```text
+die tabelle mit shop preisen
+```
+
+Erwartung: Shop-Suche wird ausgelöst, sofern Verlaufskontext vorhanden ist; sonst `Shop-Treffer: keine Suchquery` statt irreführend `nicht angefragt`.

src/Agent/AgentRunner.php

@@ -58,15 +58,15 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
         $sources = [];
         $optimizedShopQuery = '';
         $shopSearchQuery = '';
-        $forcedShopSearchQuery = '';
         $commerceHistoryContext = '';
         $attemptedShopRepair = false;
         $usedShopRepair = false;
         $shopRepairQueries = [];
         $shopSearchAttempted = false;
-        $explicitShopRoutingForced = false;
         $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure = false;
         $historyNotices = [];
+        $commerceIntent = CommerceIntentLite::NONE;
+        $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery = false;
 
         $this->agentLogger->info('Agent run started', [
             'userId' => $userId,
@@ -83,7 +83,12 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     stageLabel: 'Antwort wird vorbereitet',
                     ragCount: null,
                     shopCount: null,
-                    shopCountMode: 'not_requested',
+                    shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+                        commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                        shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                        shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                        shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                    ),
                     sourceLabels: $sources,
                     confidenceLabel: 'Beleglage wird geprüft'
                 ),
@@ -109,54 +114,44 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                 $this->addSource($sources, $this->agentRunnerConfig->getExternalUrlSourceLabel());
             }
 
-            $originalPromptHasExplicitShopSignal = $this->containsExplicitShopRoutingSignal($originalPrompt);
+            $commerceIntent = $this->detectCommerceIntentForRouting(
-            $routingPromptHasExplicitShopSignal = $this->containsExplicitShopRoutingSignal($routingPrompt);
-
-            if (
-                $originalPromptHasExplicitShopSignal
-                && !$this->isCommercialTableFollowUpPrompt($routingPrompt)
-            ) {
-                // Explicit user routing terms such as "shop" must never be lost
-                // through LLM normalization before the commerce gate is evaluated.
-                $routingPrompt = $originalPrompt;
-                $routingPromptHasExplicitShopSignal = true;
-            }
-
-            $forcedShopSearchQuery = $this->resolveForcedCommercialFollowUpShopQuery(
                 $routingPrompt,
                 $userId,
                 $requestContextHint
             );
-
+            $originalCommerceIntent = $this->detectCommerceIntentForRouting(
-            $explicitShopRoutingForced = $forcedShopSearchQuery === ''
+                $originalPrompt,
-                && ($originalPromptHasExplicitShopSignal || $routingPromptHasExplicitShopSignal);
-
-            $commerceIntent = ($forcedShopSearchQuery !== '' || $explicitShopRoutingForced)
-                ? CommerceIntentLite::PRODUCT_SEARCH
-                : $this->detectCommerceIntentForRouting(
-                    $routingPrompt,
                 $userId,
                 $requestContextHint
             );
 
-            if ($forcedShopSearchQuery !== '') {
+            if (!$this->isCommerceIntent($commerceIntent) && $this->isCommerceIntent($originalCommerceIntent)) {
-                $this->agentLogger->info('Forced commercial follow-up into shop routing', [
+                $this->agentLogger->info('Promoted normalized routing back to explicit original commerce intent', [
                     'userId' => $userId,
-                    'prompt' => $prompt,
+                    'originalPrompt' => $originalPrompt,
                     'routingPrompt' => $routingPrompt,
-                    'forcedShopSearchQuery' => $forcedShopSearchQuery,
+                    'originalCommerceIntent' => $originalCommerceIntent,
-                    'hasRequestContextHint' => trim($requestContextHint) !== '',
                 ]);
+                $commerceIntent = $originalCommerceIntent;
             }
 
-            if ($explicitShopRoutingForced) {
+            if ($this->isCommerceIntent($commerceIntent)) {
-                $this->agentLogger->info('Forced explicit shop signal into commerce routing', [
+                yield $this->systemMsg(
-                    'userId' => $userId,
+                    $this->buildProductionUiMetaMessage(
-                    'prompt' => $prompt,
+                        stageLabel: 'Shop-Routing erkannt',
-                    'routingPrompt' => $routingPrompt,
+                        ragCount: null,
-                    'originalPromptHasExplicitShopSignal' => $originalPromptHasExplicitShopSignal,
+                        shopCount: null,
-                    'routingPromptHasExplicitShopSignal' => $routingPromptHasExplicitShopSignal,
+                        shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
-                ]);
+                            commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                            shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                            shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                            shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                        ),
+                        sourceLabels: $sources,
+                        confidenceLabel: 'Shopdaten werden geprüft'
+                    ),
+                    'meta'
+                );
             }
 
             yield $this->systemMsg($this->agentRunnerConfig->getRetrieveKnowledgeMessage(), 'think');
@@ -179,7 +174,12 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     stageLabel: 'RAG-Wissen wurde durchsucht',
                     ragCount: count($knowledgeChunks),
                     shopCount: null,
-                    shopCountMode: 'not_requested',
+                    shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+                        commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                        shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                        shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                        shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                    ),
                     sourceLabels: $sources,
                     confidenceLabel: $this->resolveRagEvidenceConfidenceLabel($knowledgeEvidenceState)
                 ),
@@ -217,10 +217,6 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     $this->addSource($sources, $this->agentRunnerConfig->getConversationHistorySourceLabel());
                 }
 
-                if ($forcedShopSearchQuery !== '') {
-                    $optimizedShopQuery = '';
-                    $shopSearchQuery = $forcedShopSearchQuery;
-                } else {
                 $optimizedShopQuery = yield from $this->buildOptimizedShopQuery(
                     $routingPrompt,
                     $userId,
@@ -233,7 +229,6 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     commerceHistoryContext: $commerceHistoryContext,
                     userId: $userId
                 );
-                }
 
                 if ($shopSearchQuery === '') {
                     $this->agentLogger->info('Commerce search skipped because no concrete shop query could be resolved', [
@@ -247,6 +242,7 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                         'hasRequestContextHint' => trim($requestContextHint) !== '',
                     ]);
 
+                    $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery = true;
                     $noConcreteShopQueryMessage = $this->agentRunnerConfig->getNoConcreteShopQueryMessage();
 
                     yield $this->systemMsg(
@@ -254,7 +250,12 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                             stageLabel: 'Mehr Kontext nötig',
                             ragCount: count($knowledgeChunks),
                             shopCount: null,
-                            shopCountMode: 'not_requested',
+                            shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+                                commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                                shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                                shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                                shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                            ),
                             sourceLabels: $sources,
                             confidenceLabel: 'mehr Kontext nötig',
                             completed: true
@@ -483,7 +484,12 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     stageLabel: 'Antwort wird generiert',
                     ragCount: count($knowledgeChunks),
                     shopCount: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure ? null : ($shopSearchAttempted ? count($shopResults) : null),
-                    shopCountMode: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure ? 'unavailable' : ($shopSearchAttempted ? 'count' : 'not_requested'),
+                    shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+                        commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                        shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                        shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                        shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                    ),
                     sourceLabels: $sources,
                     confidenceLabel: $this->resolveProductionUiConfidenceLabel(
                         hasKnowledge: $this->isDirectKnowledgeEvidence($knowledgeEvidenceState),
@@ -523,7 +529,12 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     stageLabel: 'Abgeschlossen',
                     ragCount: count($knowledgeChunks),
                     shopCount: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure ? null : ($shopSearchAttempted ? count($shopResults) : null),
-                    shopCountMode: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure ? 'unavailable' : ($shopSearchAttempted ? 'count' : 'not_requested'),
+                    shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+                        commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                        shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                        shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                        shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                    ),
                     sourceLabels: $sources,
                     confidenceLabel: $this->resolveProductionUiConfidenceLabel(
                         hasKnowledge: $this->isDirectKnowledgeEvidence($knowledgeEvidenceState),
@@ -598,7 +609,12 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                     stageLabel: 'Antwort wurde unterbrochen',
                     ragCount: count($knowledgeChunks),
                     shopCount: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure ? null : ($shopSearchAttempted ? count($shopResults) : null),
-                    shopCountMode: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure ? 'unavailable' : ($shopSearchAttempted ? 'count' : 'not_requested'),
+                    shopCountMode: $this->resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+                        commerceIntent: $commerceIntent,
+                        shopSearchAttempted: $shopSearchAttempted,
+                        shopSearchHadSystemFailure: $primaryShopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+                        shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery: $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery
+                    ),
                     sourceLabels: $sources,
                     confidenceLabel: 'nicht abgeschlossen',
                     completed: true
@@ -988,76 +1004,6 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
         return (string) ($commerceMeta['intent'] ?? CommerceIntentLite::NONE);
     }
 
-    private function containsExplicitShopRoutingSignal(string $prompt): bool
-    {
-        $normalized = $this->normalizeFollowUpText($prompt);
-
-        if ($normalized === '') {
-            return false;
-        }
-
-        foreach ($this->agentRunnerConfig->getFollowUpExplicitCommercialSignalTerms() as $signal) {
-            $signal = $this->normalizeFollowUpText($signal);
-
-            if ($signal === '') {
-                continue;
-            }
-
-            $pattern = '/(?<![\p{L}\p{N}])' . preg_quote($signal, '/') . '(?![\p{L}\p{N}])/u';
-
-            if (preg_match($pattern, $normalized) === 1) {
-                return true;
-            }
-        }
-
-        return false;
-    }
-
-    private function resolveForcedCommercialFollowUpShopQuery(
-        string $prompt,
-        string $userId,
-        string $requestContextHint
-    ): string {
-        if (!$this->isCommercialTableFollowUpPrompt($prompt)) {
-            return '';
-        }
-
-        $commerceHistoryContext = $this->buildCommerceHistoryContext($userId, $requestContextHint);
-        $query = $this->resolveCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery($commerceHistoryContext, $userId);
-
-        if ($query !== '' && !$this->isMetaOnlyShopQuery($query)) {
-            return $query;
-        }
-
-        $contextQuery = $this->extractContextualShopSearchQuery($commerceHistoryContext);
-        if ($contextQuery !== '' && !$this->isMetaOnlyShopQuery($contextQuery)) {
-            return $contextQuery;
-        }
-
-        $extendedHistoryBudget = $this->agentRunnerConfig->getShopQueryContextFallbackHistoryBudgetChars();
-        if ($extendedHistoryBudget > mb_strlen($commerceHistoryContext, 'UTF-8')) {
-            $extendedHistory = $this->contextService->buildUserContextWithinBudget($userId, $extendedHistoryBudget);
-            $contextQuery = $this->extractContextualShopSearchQuery($extendedHistory);
-
-            if ($contextQuery !== '' && !$this->isMetaOnlyShopQuery($contextQuery)) {
-                return $contextQuery;
-            }
-        }
-
-        if ($this->agentRunnerConfig->shouldUseFullHistoryForShopQueryContextFallback()) {
-            $fullHistory = $this->contextService->buildUserContext($userId, true);
-            $contextQuery = $this->extractContextualShopSearchQuery($fullHistory);
-
-            if ($contextQuery !== '' && !$this->isMetaOnlyShopQuery($contextQuery)) {
-                return $contextQuery;
-            }
-        }
-
-        // Last-resort fallback for explicit commercial table follow-ups.
-        // This keeps the request in the shop path instead of falling back to RAG-only.
-        return trim($this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpQueryTemplateWithoutModel());
-    }
-
     private function detectCommerceIntentForRouting(
         string $prompt,
         string $userId,
@@ -1073,12 +1019,9 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
             return $commerceIntent;
         }
 
-        $commerceHistoryContext = $this->buildCommerceHistoryContext($userId, $requestContextHint);
-
         $this->agentLogger->info('Promoted commercial table follow-up to shop intent', [
             'userId' => $userId,
             'prompt' => $prompt,
-            'hasHistoryAnchor' => $this->commercialTableFollowUpHistoryHasAnchor($commerceHistoryContext),
             'hasRequestContextHint' => trim($requestContextHint) !== '',
         ]);
 
@@ -1281,7 +1224,7 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
         $parts = preg_split($this->agentRunnerConfig->getFollowUpHistoryTurnSplitPattern(), $history);
 
         if ($parts === false || $parts === []) {
-            return [$history];
+            return [];
         }
 
         $turns = array_values(array_filter(
@@ -1443,15 +1386,14 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
         string $userId
     ): string {
         if ($this->isCommercialTableFollowUpPrompt($prompt)) {
-            $commercialTableContextQuery = $this->resolveCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery(
+            foreach ($this->buildCommercialTableFollowUpContextCandidates($commerceHistoryContext, $userId) as $contextCandidate) {
-                $commerceHistoryContext,
+                $commercialTableContextQuery = $this->extractCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery($contextCandidate);
-                $userId
-            );
 
                 if ($commercialTableContextQuery !== '' && !$this->isMetaOnlyShopQuery($commercialTableContextQuery)) {
                     return $commercialTableContextQuery;
                 }
             }
+        }
 
         if ($optimizedShopQuery !== '' && !$this->isMetaOnlyShopQuery($optimizedShopQuery)) {
             return $optimizedShopQuery;
@@ -1490,32 +1432,34 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
         return '';
     }
 
-    private function resolveCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery(string $commerceHistoryContext, string $userId): string
+    /**
+     * @return string[]
+     */
+    private function buildCommercialTableFollowUpContextCandidates(string $commerceHistoryContext, string $userId): array
     {
-        $query = $this->extractCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery($commerceHistoryContext);
+        $candidates = [];
 
-        if ($query !== '') {
+        $commerceHistoryContext = trim($commerceHistoryContext);
-            return $query;
+        if ($commerceHistoryContext !== '') {
+            $candidates[] = $commerceHistoryContext;
         }
 
         $extendedHistoryBudget = $this->agentRunnerConfig->getShopQueryContextFallbackHistoryBudgetChars();
-
         if ($extendedHistoryBudget > mb_strlen($commerceHistoryContext, 'UTF-8')) {
-            $extendedHistory = $this->contextService->buildUserContextWithinBudget($userId, $extendedHistoryBudget);
+            $extendedHistory = trim($this->contextService->buildUserContextWithinBudget($userId, $extendedHistoryBudget));
-            $query = $this->extractCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery($extendedHistory);
+            if ($extendedHistory !== '') {
-
+                $candidates[] = $extendedHistory;
-            if ($query !== '') {
-                return $query;
             }
         }
 
         if ($this->agentRunnerConfig->shouldUseFullHistoryForShopQueryContextFallback()) {
-            return $this->extractCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery(
+            $fullHistory = trim($this->contextService->buildUserContext($userId, true));
-                $this->contextService->buildUserContext($userId, true)
+            if ($fullHistory !== '') {
-            );
+                $candidates[] = $fullHistory;
+            }
         }
 
-        return '';
+        return array_values(array_unique($candidates));
     }
 
     private function extractCommercialTableFollowUpShopQuery(string $commerceHistoryContext): string
@@ -1524,7 +1468,7 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
             return '';
         }
 
-        $hasIndicatorContext = false;
+        $fallbackWithoutModel = '';
 
         foreach ($this->extractHistoryTurnsNewestFirst($commerceHistoryContext) as $turn) {
             if (!$this->matchesAnyConfiguredPattern(
@@ -1534,7 +1478,6 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
                 continue;
             }
 
-            $hasIndicatorContext = true;
             $model = $this->extractFirstTestomatModelAnchor($turn);
 
             if ($model !== '') {
@@ -1546,13 +1489,11 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
 
                 return trim((string) preg_replace('/\s+/u', ' ', $query));
             }
+
+            $fallbackWithoutModel = trim($this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpQueryTemplateWithoutModel());
         }
 
-        if ($hasIndicatorContext) {
+        return $fallbackWithoutModel;
-            return trim($this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpQueryTemplateWithoutModel());
-        }
-
-        return '';
     }
 
     private function isCommercialTableFollowUpPrompt(string $prompt): bool
@@ -1561,47 +1502,9 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
             return false;
         }
 
-        $normalized = $this->normalizeFollowUpText($prompt);
-
-        if ($this->matchesAnyConfiguredPattern(
-            $normalized,
-            $this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpPromptPatterns()
-        )) {
-            return true;
-        }
-
-        $tokens = $this->tokenizeMetaGuardText($normalized);
-        if ($tokens === []) {
-            return false;
-        }
-
-        $hasTableReference = count(array_intersect(
-            $tokens,
-            $this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpTableTerms()
-        )) > 0;
-
-        if (!$hasTableReference) {
-            return false;
-        }
-
-        foreach ($this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpCommercialTerms() as $term) {
-            if (in_array($this->normalizeFollowUpText($term), $tokens, true)) {
-                return true;
-            }
-        }
-
-        return false;
-    }
-
-    private function commercialTableFollowUpHistoryHasAnchor(string $commerceHistoryContext): bool
-    {
-        if (trim($commerceHistoryContext) === '') {
-            return false;
-        }
-
         return $this->matchesAnyConfiguredPattern(
-            $commerceHistoryContext,
+            $this->normalizeFollowUpText($prompt),
-            $this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpHistoryAnchorPatterns()
+            $this->agentRunnerConfig->getCommercialTableFollowUpPromptPatterns()
         );
     }
 
@@ -2632,6 +2535,31 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
         return trim($value);
     }
 
+    private function resolveShopCountModeForMeta(
+        string $commerceIntent,
+        bool $shopSearchAttempted,
+        bool $shopSearchHadSystemFailure,
+        bool $shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery = false
+    ): string {
+        if ($shopSearchHadSystemFailure) {
+            return 'unavailable';
+        }
+
+        if ($shopSearchAttempted) {
+            return 'count';
+        }
+
+        if ($shopSearchSkippedBecauseNoQuery) {
+            return 'not_resolved';
+        }
+
+        if ($this->isCommerceIntent($commerceIntent)) {
+            return 'loading';
+        }
+
+        return 'not_requested';
+    }
+
     /**
      * @param string[] $sourceLabels
      */
@@ -2652,6 +2580,7 @@ final readonly class AgentRunner
             'count' => 'Shop-Treffer: ' . max(0, (int) $shopCount),
             'loading' => 'Shop-Treffer: wird geladen',
             'unavailable' => 'Shop-Treffer: nicht verfügbar',
+            'not_resolved' => 'Shop-Treffer: keine Suchquery',
             default => 'Shop-Treffer: nicht angefragt',
         };
         $statusLabel = $completed ? 'Status: abgeschlossen' : 'Status: läuft';