25 lines
2.3 KiB
Markdown
25 lines
2.3 KiB
Markdown
Rate each subblock of the topic "{topic}" by relevance: relevant or peripheral. The relevance controls whether a point goes into the focused guides or only into the complete guide.
|
|
|
|
SUBBLOCKS (in brackets the parent block of the number; many state their core points with "Kern:"):
|
|
{subblocks}
|
|
|
|
Use the core points for a well-grounded rating — judge on the content, not just the title.
|
|
|
|
Relevance:
|
|
- **relevant**: core/standard knowledge that CARRIES the topic — central concepts, definitions, properties, common practice. For practical topics: what you need in actual use. For theoretical topics: central theorems/properties, EVEN without practical use. What you genuinely should know.
|
|
- **peripheral**: a side note, special/niche case, "nice to know", deprecated/exotic — PLUS purely historical details (who/when), concrete numeric examples of a general principle, mere cross-references. NOT peripheral: a central theorem or a fundamental property just because it seems "theoretical". Belongs only in a complete guide.
|
|
|
|
Rules:
|
|
- These subblocks **all already** belong to the topic — the question is not *whether* but *how central*. Judge **core vs. peripheral within its own block**, one at a time.
|
|
- **The basic syntax / core rule of a block — what the block TITLE promises — is NEVER peripheral.** A block "Headings" without its heading syntax marked relevant is broken. Check this per block before anything else.
|
|
- **When the BLOCK itself is a fringe/extension feature** (non-standard, niche, an add-on rather than core of the topic), only its basic syntax and purpose are relevant — its detail rules and special cases are `peripheral`. A fringe feature must not be decomposed deeper than the core topics (measured: a non-standard block carried 22 "relevant" detail rules while core blocks had 6).
|
|
- `peripheral` is a **genuine category** for clear cases: nice-to-know, special/niche cases, detail/numeric examples, historical notes, cross-references, style tips.
|
|
- `peripheral` items are CUT from the focused guides — a wrong `peripheral` loses content, a wrong `relevant` only adds a paragraph. **When in doubt → relevant.**
|
|
- Only judge — invent nothing, change no subblocks.
|
|
|
|
Reply with ONLY the JSON — no other text, no code fences.
|
|
|
|
Format (exactly one value for EACH number; no other text):
|
|
{{"relevance": {{"1": "relevant", "2": "peripheral", "3": "relevant"}}}}
|
|
{extra}
|